I hope your Rosh Hashanah was uplifting. Personally, I was inspired by our shaliach tzibbur (which is good because, as many of you know, I’m married to him), and by the commentary in R. Sacks’s machzor. More about that in a moment.
If you’d like a dose of inspiration as you prepare for Yom Kippur, check out these blasts from the 2020 Torah past:
Recordings of:
Forgiving Difficult People, with Dr Elliott Malamet
The Poems of Kol Nidrei and the Amidah of Ne’ilah with Rabba Dr Lindsey Taylor-Guthartz
You can also choose from dozens of recordings on Jewish topics by scrolling through our events listings.
Turning to Shabbat Shuva, this week’s Covenant and Conversation on Ha’azinu struck a chord with me, even before I noticed that R. Sacks had quoted one of my favourite passages from Emmanuel Levinas:
The Revelation has a particular way of producing meaning, which lies in its calling upon the unique within me. It is as if a multiplicity of persons... were the condition for the plenitude of ‘absolute truth,’ as if each person, by virtue of his own uniqueness, were able to guarantee the revelation of one unique aspect of the truth, so that some of its facets would never have been revealed if certain people had been absent from mankind. ‘Revelation in the Jewish Tradition,’ in The Levinas Reader, ed. Sean Hand (Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2001), pp. 190–210.
The Ha’azinu piece is a beautiful reflection on the value that Judaism ascribes to individuality and diversity:
‘The miracle of creation is that unity in heaven produces diversity on earth. Torah is the rain that feeds this diversity, allowing each of us to become what only we can be.’
Back to the Rosh Hashanah machzor. Much as I enjoy Ian’s davvening, I am often drawn to the bottom of the page to see what R. Sacks has to say. This year I was fascinated by his discussion of the contradiction between the words of Unetaneh Tokef, the most famous part of the Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur liturgy, immortalised by Leonard Cohen in his song ‘Who by fire?’, and our confident assertion moments later that teshuva, tefilla, and tzedakah annul the evil decree.
Rabbi Sacks says that the Jewish people live in the cognitive dissonance between these passages and ideas. ‘This dissonance,’ he says, ‘is the source of our creative energy, our restless desire to heal a fractured world, as well as our intellectual honesty in refusing to simplify a complex faith.’
A few pages later, in his commentary on v’chol ma’aminim, ‘And all believe,’ Rabbi Sacks explores this dissonance in greater depth. Rosh Hashanah, he writes, is
‘the living expression of Judaism’s greatest leap of faith: the belief that the world is ruled by justice. No idea has been more revolutionary, and none more perplexing.’
It is perplexing because, so often, when we look around the world, we don’t see divine justice. We see its absence. The righteous suffer. A post-Holocaust generation, and now a post-October 7 generation, don’t need to be reminded of this. Yet in our prayers we assert that God is good and the world is ruled by justice.
Why not just abandon this belief? Wouldn’t that be the most rational thing to do?
Rabbi Sacks responds by asserting that without the belief in divine justice, ‘life is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.’ And he reminds us that even the greatest prophets were perplexed and distraught at the suffering of the innocent. Job protested his own innocence. Ecclesiastes says, ‘I saw the tears of the oppressed, and they have no comforter’ (Ecclesiastes 4:1). Lamentations says, ‘The Lord has become like an enemy’ (Lamentations 2:5).
These are not comfortable texts. They are not meant to be. Biblical faith does not resolve this perplexity. It accepts it. It holds the tension without collapsing it into easy answers. And it insists that the proper response to suffering is not despair but action.
On a personal note, this is where I first encountered any kind of Jewish philosophy. My undergraduate supervisor at Trent University in Canada was the late John Burbidge, a Christian scholar who had studied under Emil Fackenheim.
Fackenheim was a Jewish philosopher, a refugee from Nazi Germany, who became most famous for the idea that after the Holocaust there is a 614th commandment: the Jewish people must survive and refuse to hand Hitler any posthumous victories. When Professor Burbidge learned of my Jewish background, he actively encouraged me to explore my heritage, even taking me to the local Conservative synagogue one Saturday morning, introducing me to people at kiddush, and lending me audio tapes of Fackenheim giving public lectures in his heavily accented English.
Little did I know then that he was seeding what would, a few years later, become my specialist academic subject: post-Holocaust Jewish thought.
Back to Rabbi Sacks: ‘The faith of the Bible,’ he writes, ‘is neither optimistic nor naïve. It contains no theodicies, no systematic answers, no easy consolations.’
The word ‘theodicy’ might not be familiar to everyone. In my early years of giving adult education classes on post-Holocaust thought, I once explained the problem of evil and then asked the group if they were familiar with ‘theodicy’. ‘Of course,’ one eager woman replied, ‘that’s an epic poem by Homer.’
These days, of course, she might have said, ‘That’s a great movie, I saw it at the Imax theatre.’
In a future post, I do plan to write about Judaism and The Odyssey. But back to theodicy. It is a philosophical term, coined by Leibniz, that combines the Latin words for God and justice. Theodicies are one type of answer to the problem of evil, answers that, in some way, take God’s side. We ask why the innocent suffer, and the proponents of theodicy might say: you only think they are innocent, but they have sinned; or they are innocent, but God is justified in allowing them to suffer because somehow this creates a greater good. Probably the best-known answer is the free will defence: God created humans with free will, which means that they have the freedom to do bad things, and the innocent will be the victims of these evil deeds.
Some theodicies will stop there, at the level of explanation, and others will go further, and argue that God is fully justified in creating the world in such a way, and in refraining from intervening even when things go catastrophically badly, because this, somehow, generates a greater good. I’ll leave the details of these sorts of arguments for another time. Or perhaps never!
For now, let’s go back to Rabbi Sacks:
The prophets, he says, didn’t ask their questions about suffering because they didn’t believe in divine justice, but, on the contrary, they were troubled precisely because they did believe.
‘If there were no Judge, there would be no justice and no question. There is a Judge.’
So, when will we see justice?
Jewish thought, Rabbi Sacks insists, ‘has been a sustained meditation on this question, never finding a final answer, realizing that here was a sacred mystery no human mind could penetrate. All other requests Moses made on behalf of the Jewish people, says the Talmud (Berakhot 7a) were granted except this: to understand why the righteous suffer.’
A word of explanation: when Moses asks to see the Face of God, God has him hide in the cleft of the rock and view God from behind (Exodus 33:18–23), because ‘No man can see My face and live’ (Exodus 33:20). One interpretation of this story is that Moses’s request had been to understand why the wicked sometimes prosper and the righteous sometimes suffer (Exodus 33:13; Berakhot 7a).
Personally, I was relieved to find these ideas in Rabbi Sacks’s machzor, because just a few days before, a Muslim colleague had told me about struggling to support a friend whose son had recently been murdered. My colleague’s friend told her that well-meaning people had tried to comfort her, but nothing they said had helped. My colleague didn’t offer any consoling words or defence of God’s ways. She just listened.
I told her that I thought she had done exactly the right thing and referred her to the Book of Job. I explained that at the end of the book, God is critical of Job’s so-called friends and their misguided attempts at ‘comforting’ him, largely by blaming him for his own suffering (Job 42:7–9).
Even though I was pretty confident in what I told my colleague, I was relieved, on Rosh Hashanah, to have the voice of Rabbi Sacks in my head, underscoring that the best, most honest religious answer to the question ‘Why do the innocent suffer?’ is, ultimately, ‘We don’t know.’
Why do bad things happen to good people?
We don’t know.
We just don’t know.


Happy New Year! I really appreciated your reflections. A long time ago I did a masters thesis on German-Jewish literature and studied Hebrew and Yiddish. Jewish culture and history is dear to my heart. Also, I’d absolutely love to read reflections from you on Judaism and the Odyssey!
I’m looking forward to reading your reflections on Judaism and the Odyssey. Tzom kal.